1 month ago. December 7, 2024 at 8:41 AM
I would hope that all here are already familiar with the term Consent. I would hazard a guess that a lot of you are also familiar with the idea of Consent as a Scale rather than a singular thing (think of 0-255 rather than a 0-1). I would also hope that anyone here is aware that consent is an ongoing thing, not a One and Done thing... but that is a conversation for another time.
This concept of Consent being on a scale is especially important in a BDSM setting, but equally important even in Vanilla life too. Both sexually, kink wise, and outside of the bedroom as well (medically etc).
For anyone who is unaware of what I mean, here is how I see the scale, others may add or disagree here, but this is my scale. I will also be ignoring lack of Consent for the most part to just stick to the idea of Given Consent itself (I shall also be avoiding CNC, as this is a whole can of worms that I personally will not get involved in, you do you boo, you do you).
The Consent Scale (complete with crappy titles for each level):
Enthusiastic Consent - This is wherein someone not only gives consent, but actively wants to give consent. An example could be someone who wants to be flogged, it has always been a fantasy of theirs, and they were hoping that you would ask. It could be someone who wants to have a sexual encounter, has been longing for it, wanting it, needing it for a while, and once asked, doesn't even have to think for a moment, just jumps on it... literally in some cases ;)
This is the level of Consent I am most comfortable with, it is the only level of consent that makes me happy to receive or give (for personal reasons, having not given consent in the past, and had that lack of consent ignored). If someone is enthusiastically consenting to something I have asked to do (in whatever form that may take, from "Give me your number" to "give me your soul"), that turns me on... ok... maybe not when someone enthusiastically says "YES! YES! PLEASE LET ME MAKE A CUP OF TEA!"... then I might be a little concerned as to why they really want to make a cup of tea so badly that they are almost orgasming at the thought of it... but you get my drift.
Sure Consent - The next level is "I am consenting, I don't really want to right now, but know I will enjoy this once it gets started and will be happy it happened afterwards" This is where someone may not actively want to do something at the time, they may not be sure that they are in the mood, not physically feeling it but mentally there, they may even just be caught off guard. Sometimes when you get in from doing the adulting, someone suddenly asking "hey wanna do X, Y, or Z?" all things you enjoy normally, but you just weren't expecting it right now. So you consent to it, knowing that you would really enjoy it after it started, but were unsure of whether to start right now... This is still Consent, just not as Consenting as Enthusiastically Consenting... this is "I Guess" consent.
This is a soft limit for me, if someone is in "I Guess" mode, I may need some convincing that we should proceed. I would likely question whether now was the right time, and likely prefer that we can do it later on, or when the other person/s are in the mood. If the person was SURE that actually I have turned "I Guess" into Enthusiastic Consent, then I would move forward. BUT, it would have to be a 100% thing for me.
"If it makes you happy" Consent - This is when someone doesn't want to do something for their pleasure, but for the pleasure of the person asking... I cannot bring myself to enjoy this, either giving or receiving. If I get the inclining that someone is in "If it makes you happy" mode, I am immediately turned off. I just don't want to continue at this point, and will default to "Oh no, I have a headache, maybe another time" or "Oh damn, I forgot I have to do some adulting" and postpone or cancel entirely. If someone is only doing this "For Me", since I do not value myself as much as I value those I care about, I simply don't want it... I can take care of my carnal desires easily enough all on my own, and don't need the guilt that comes with this kind of consent eating away at me for the rest of time. This is a Hard Limit for me, as are all following grades.
I have been in the position of giving "If it makes you happy" consent with a previous partner. I was good friends with them at the time, and they were going though a really rough patch (their partner was cheating on her, she was feeling depressed, unlovable, and undesirable). I agreed to a sexual encounter, even though I knew it would affect our friendship later down the line, and only gave it as I knew they needed it at that point in time. They REALLY needed it, and despite my not really wanting to, I wanted to see them happy again, so that she could see that she was beautiful, that she deserved better. I felt like crap afterwards, sure it was sexually enjoyable in a physical sense (the only Sex I have ever not enjoyed was non-consensual), and it was exceptionally nice to see them happy (It made her see how awful her then partner was, and she subsequently left them for someone better), but I knew that what I had done was give them a short term fix, that left me feeling mildly violated. I was too young and inexperienced to voice this with them, to ask them to respect my boundaries at the time, and I deeply regret doing it to this day, even if it meant she ended up in a better place (she is now happily married). We are still friends... ish. I still talk to her from time to time, but we have never been the same since. I miss our friendship. Had it been under different circumstances, had she and I both been enthusiastic about it, rather than just her, I would have felt differently about it... I mean, she wasn't exactly unattractive (she is a pretty lady), and the things she could do in bed were... well... educational... anyway, I valued our friendship more, and feel I gave that up for her to be happy for that time.
Anything below this is NOT Consent in my eyes, despite it technically being so in some places (at least legally speaking).
"Oh, I have to do this" or "It's My Duty" Consent - An example would be a wife who is utterly not interested in sex or doing something kinky, deciding that it is her duty to perform for her partner as it is their anniversary (or vice versa). This is not really much better than indentured servitude in my eyes. Some people may be ok with this, whether receiving or giving consent, but this is not ok for me, and is absolutely OFF the damn table. I want truth, honesty, and openness, otherwise, I do not want it.
"I have to do this to stop this person being angry/depressed/sad" or "Appease the Douche" Consent - (please note that douches can be male or female or any shade in between). I cannot ever see any situation where this is Consent. While it may be legally consent in some places, this is Forced Consent, and is therefore NOT consent.
A darker version of "It's My Duty" Consent is "It's YOUR Duty" Consent... this is fucked up, and is emotional blackmail. Someone who makes someone feel like they MUST doing something, like they HAVE to agree to something, is fucked up. REALLY fucked up. Whether you are male, female, or any of the wonderful shades of grey in between, Your Body, Your Choice. Never accept anyone who tells you that you have to do something like this. Fuck that, Don't Fuck Them, Leave.
"Lack Of Legal" Consent - If someone is not mentally able to give consent, due to age, being on certain drugs (whether knowingly or not), or varying states of consciousness, then they have not given consent even if they have verbally given consent. An example would be someone who was very drunk, and gave consent to a sexual act, but under normal circumstances would not have. This is where thankfully most places decide that consent ends, and is no longer freely given... but there are a few places around the world where even this is "Given Consent"... if you live there, I am so sorry for you, and hope that you can either get the fuck out, or that the law and attitudes change fast.
I will not go further into this, as pretty much anything else from here on down is just too disgusting to think about. Having been there, having felt what it's like when someone disregards your existence is such a way as to not only ignore the lack of consent, but laugh about it both during and afterwards, to then joke about it with others in front of you, anything else is just too raw for me to really talk about. At least unless it was to help someone else who had been through it, and then, it would only be in a person to person setting rather than as a Random Blog Post.
There are surely shades in between these, nuances and special cases, but on the whole I think this covers most of the shades of consent and a dipping of toes into Non-Consent.
I hope that nobody has experienced anything below "Sure" Consent, but I fear that they most assuredly have as the Human Race is a disgusting and vile creature at the best of times. Sure, there are individuals who are exceptional, wonderful, beautiful people, whom the gods would be honoured to gaze upon from afar, but there are a hell of a lot of folks who are just awful. Here is hoping that they get some Karma their way, and know exactly WHY they got it... In other highly optimistic news, this weeks wall of text has finally finished, and if you made it this far, you are far more patient than me.
Peace and Love you inglorious bastards, may your deepest and darkest desires see the Enthusiastically Consensual light of day!