". . . it is this very type of question that in all honesty, is what I consider to be a part of the problem. Stepping away from “tradition” and “finding our own way” only works effectively if we have a solid foundation of knowledge to work with in the first place… otherwise it’s simply the “blind” leading the “blind.”
@ Bunny
Hi Bunny!
I try to explain my point of view but that doesn't mean it is clear. I see things in pictures and explain them by drawing. I can't do that if I am using only words!
So, here I go...It is my nature to question; even my own perception. If the sky is purple but the sun is not I want to know why. If someone is a fallible human and calls themselves an expert I don't take it at face value. You could also say it is a yellow flag for me when there is talk of someone being superior to another person. (Not at all implying that is what your talking about but am referencing the term
*expert.)
As for Jay Wiseman ( I am familiar with his work) , he doesn't take himself too seriously. He has a sense of humor, and always open to learning more. His work is of (great) benefit to others. I have concern with those who consider themselves experts and their work may help others but is primarily of benefit to their ego. (ouch, squishing my eyes as I typed that word) Quickly moving on...
Few other things:
1 - So when you say "problem" - assuming you mean "the blind leading the blind". Meaning those who are not experienced or knowledgeable giving advice to someone who isn't experienced. (engaging in the art of BDSM without experience) I'm going to challenge this a little.
When the word *problem comes to mind we might be thinking of a mistake, a wrong, or someone being hurt. How I wish we could all avoid mistakes and getting hurt. How realistic is this? Certainly desirable as no one wants to be hurt and most don't care to hurt others. If we were to take a vote of those who read this thread I would venture to guess we have all made mistakes. Mistakes engaging in BDSM. Even Jay Wiseman. And like Jay, we can learn!
2 - I would very much like to know what is in your mind when you say "tradition". I have some idea but don' t want to presume. Help me understand, please.
I'm not skipping over the fact that safety should be number one. But I don't see how trying to experience BDSM can be done without making mistakes. It is just an aspect of life. In all of life we make mistakes. We have problems. I, for one, would like to think we can work through our problems and grow through learning.
To end, I wanted to share a picture in my head. When you said blind leading the blind I scanned (my brain)for an image. I pictured a toddler who wants to walk helping a toddler learn to walk. At first, I thought this was a good example to support your usage of the phrase. And then I realized that toddlers learn to walk not by an adult ( expert walker) guiding them. They learn to walk by exploring their world. They crawl, then stand and fall many times. They learn to walk by finding their own way. But they do see examples and emulate. So this would speak to not polarizing idea of how to engage in BDSM. Instead, to seek knowledge but also trust yourself in that you will learn. Be cautious, yes! But also go after what you want and know you can work through the problems that will inevitably occur.
( see look - I wrote a book and I am not an expert

Sorry couldn't resist.