Ooh, I feel compelled to pick up this cudgel and run with it!
You asked for some constructive criticism and my cold medicine is working
I want to make it clear I'm attacking your arguments, not you as a person. I don't know you so I can't judge you or your character, only the argument you're putting forward here.
>Ok, so I've been lurking in the background of this scene for a few years now. However due to unfortunate circumstances have been almost entirely unable to engage with any Dominants in person. So my limited experience with Doms comes almost solely from online interactions.
You've recently created an account here, and claim to have had very limited experiences with Dominants in an online environment, on which you're basing the controversial opinion that all Dominants are doing this for reasons tied up in "arrogance, entitlement and ego-stroking." You've rattled The Cage
Strike one. Correlation does not imply causation. Just because you've encountered a lot of IG and TikTok wannabe doms doesn't mean all Dominants are that way. Just like all squares are rectangles, not all rectangles are squares. Life is like that sometimes.
>"I understand that "online Dom's" are almost always going to have issues, otherwise I would expect them to be "Real-life Dom's" with real, physical partners/submissives.
Dominants, like most people in the world today, exist both online and offline. I have physical partners, as well as online partners. I would argue that you get both ends of the spectrum with regards to stability, attitude, reliability, etc. online and offline. Same as any other cross-section of humanity. This is not exclusive to the BDSM/kink/fetish scene either. It's just people.
>(besides, we all know that anonymity, especially the kind that the internet provides brings out the worst in humanity.)
It definitely can.
>But the overwhelming number of self proclaimed "Dom's" who exude arrogance and seem to expect the world to be handed to them on a silver platter, and beg them to take it too. Is becoming...kind of worrying.
I would ask where you're meeting these people. I would also ask how much exposure to the community and education you've had in the BDSM/kink/fetish scene, in general. Further upthread I remember seeing you not knowing what OTK meant, a basic BDSM term (meaning Over The Knee, in regards to spanking. Also a kind of boot I adore.) This is not a knock on you, I learn new things every day.
Again, this is okay, COVID made things hard for many people to get started the last few years.
But if you are making blanket statements about how Dominants are basically heartless trash, it does beg the question how much exposure to the community outside of the DMs you have had.
>So many seem to expect others to submit to them with no questions asked, no limits, no choice and no respect. Just total unconditional control and surrender.
For me, when I meet a potential partner, I need to get to know them. I don't trust someone that offers it up right away. It means they don't care about me and don't want to serve *me*, they just want a kink dispenser.
If I don't know their psychological makeup, I don't know their interests, or what they've done in the past, I don't know what buttons to push. I don't know what's safe for them, what their limits are. I don't want a "plug and play submissive", I want a thinking, breathing, creative human being. We'll have vanilla conversations, we talk about our day. I encourage them to do well, I learn all the little buttons, snaps and zips to tug and pull as we go while we are part of each others' lives. It doesn't just happen right away, it's a serious time investment and I want to know that we are truly compatible.
>I don't know if this means I'm just a bad Sub or if having self-respect is antithetical to being submissive in general. But as someone who likes to know that they are entertaining others and kind of enjoys being controlled. But also likes and wants to be acknowledged and rewarded for their dedication and service. I'm starting to get the impression that I'm either missing some important part of this puzzle or some important aspect of myself.
Another red flag. Binary thinking. It is not one or the other. Power exchange means having the ability to withdraw from the exchange at any time. You have the ability to say no, to say fuck this shit, at any moment you feel uncomfortable.
And the Dominant has to respect that. If they don't? That's not you being a bad sub, or being antithetical to the submissive ethos. That's exactly what power exchange is. You are not powerless to leave, you are empowered to stay.
But that also means if you're going beyond what the Dominant feels comfortable or willing to put up with the Dominant can also withdraw and move on. Very basic power exchange stuff here.
Your post, whether you meant for it to or not, came off as someone who has had some bad interactions and has become embittered towards the scene and Dominants. Someone who makes broad generalizations, demands we prove your (perhaps misconceived on our part) conceptions wrong, but also doesn't know some very basic stuff. Those red flags.
People are very complex, each doing this thing for their own reason. I have a little dark part inside me that needs to be fed with the discomfort of others and pictures of men wearing panties. Am I arrogant or entitled? No. I treasure all the people that engage with me in this way. They enrich my life as much as I enrich theirs. We have a great deal of fun, as we define fun. That's different for everyone, and that's why compatibility is so important.
I would encourage you to keep learning! To keep engaging with the community here and other places. To not internalize negative experiences when you find them, because sometimes a person is just not for you and that is 100% okay.
And to know if you make a blanket statement about a group of people, they are going to get in their feelings about it. This is actually a great place to land, it's one of my favorite kink hangs online. People are really friendly and welcoming, especially the chatroom once it starts rolling.