serenitymuse wrote:
I have run in to two men in my life who emphatically do not believe in apologies.
One says that life is too short for apologies. The other says that they are typically empty of heart and just serving to selfishly alleviate ones guilt.
Yeah, wow, i think this can be a complex topic.
To the first guy, i think life is too short to hold grudges, but not to apologize. To me an apology is just openness and honesty, owning it when we fuck up. That, to me, is a vital part of any relationship? To not acknowledge and express regret for an offense is to fill the room with the proverbial 'elephants.' It makes it hard, maybe impossible, for the offended to move on or gain understanding as to 'why' the offense happened. i think leaving out apologies will ultimately undermine a relationship, weigh it down with unpacked baggage vs unpacking the baggage. We back bags when we are going away.
The second guys reason has some points. i don't agree with throwing out the baby with the bathwater, but an apology isn't always as simple as just saying "sorry." Some people are expert at being gauche or using apologies to deflect or dodge from the real issue.
i met a guy online on the 4th and he stated he'd come by at 9, after time with his family. i got prepared for him, delayed dinner, and he didn't show, no word as to why. A day later i get a note from him saying: "hey, sorry, things got a bit weird last night." To me, that's not a real apology, it's closer to the sort of thing the second guy described. The offense was not that something happened to prevent him from keeping his date but that he left me hanging without an explanation. It's 2020. He has a cell phone, it would have taken less than a minute to send a note/text: "hey, sorry, something has come up and i won't be able to make it," or something similar. His offense was he was inconsiderate and left me hanging, but he didn't acknowledge or apologize for that, his 'apology' was "empty."
Some people use apologies to shift blame. Some manipulate an apology to make the offended feel badly for being offended.
On the other side, some use apology as a power play. I.e., an apology becomes an opportunity for them to bank offenses to use against the offender, or to punish, not as a way to deal with an offense, but to retain it. And of course, that's complicated too. Not every offense can be easily fixed by an apology. Then there are repeat offenses for the same thing.
Not a simple topic. i don't believe the complexity of the topic means it's okay to forego apology, but i don't think it's always a simple, cut and dried, topic.